In 1940, Villa Zora was requisitioned by the Fascist authorities to serve as the headquarters of the Youth Fascist organization (Gioventù Italiana del Littorio). The synagogue was damaged, but the most precious Judaica including silver ceremonial lamps and Torah scrolls had been hidden in a safe place by synagogue caretaker Francesco Lettis (or Letiš) to be returned at the end of the war.
On 28 June of the same year, the Rijeka prefect Temistocle Testa (1897-1949) ordered that Bernard Nathan, president of the Jewish community of Opatija, be interned at the Campagna internment camp near Salerno in Southern Italy. Nathan was subsequently transferred to the Lagonegro camp in the Province of Potenza under the status of “free internee”. Released on 16 June 1943, he returned for a short time to Opatija and then escaped from that city after the armistice was signed on 8 September 1943. He ultimately took refuge with his family in the countryside outside Udine.
On 15 August 1943, Carlo Steiner (1869-date of death unknown), who had been appointed president of the Jewish community of Opatija by the Rijeka Prefecture after Nathan’s internment, informed the Union of the Italian Jewish Communities that he had asked the prefect of Rijeka, Agostino Podestà (1905-1969) to restore Villa Zora to a place of worship. Steiner also requested that a commission of experts be established to estimate both the scope of damages to the synagogue and the value of the Judaica that had been located in the synagogue before requisition and later lost.